Finance report warns parachute payments dividing Championship

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Championship football may be turning into a "two-tier competition" due to the impact of parachute payments, a new Business of Sport report has revealed.

The Football Finance Report - produced by Leonard Curtis, a national professional services group which works with businesses across Cumbria - found that recipients of parachute payment are more than four times as likely to win promotion than other clubs.

The report's Financial Performance Index, ranking clubs based on their financial and sporting performance for the 2024/25 season, showed the growing influence of parachute payments on a club’s financial position.

Leeds United, Sheffield United, Burnley and Luton Town, who were all in receipt of parachute payments, made up almost 40 per cent of the league's entire revenue (£920.3m) in 2024/25.

In the last two reported seasons (2023/24 and 2024/25), the average revenue advantage of clubs in receipt of parachute payments was as high as £62-66m per club.

The figures also suggest that clubs with parachute payments were more than four times as likely to win promotion as those without them over the ten-year period.

Championship play-off finalThe Championship is widely regarded as one of the most popular and entertaining divisions in football - but spending at this level has been described as "unsustainable". (Image: Wikipedia)

The report, authored by a team of sports business journalists and leading football finance academics, including Prof Rob Wilson and Dr Dan Plumley, also included a foreword written by former West Ham, Wolves and Norwich City player Matt Jarvis.

The findings were launched at an event at the National Football Museum in Manchester on September 16, where discussion of the report underlined the growing challenges the Championship faces around spending control.

The data shows that while league revenues grew from £546.5m in 2015/16 to £920.3m in 2024/25, the combined wages-to-turnover ratio never fell below 91 per cent.

In 2024/25, 13 of 23 reporting clubs spent more on wages than their entire turnover (Sheffield Wednesday did not file accounts for the year due to being in administration).

Alex Cadwallader, a director and insolvency practitioner at Leonard Curtis, said: "The overarching story to emerge from this report is the growing structural inequality in the Championship, alongside a financial model that remains difficult to sustain.

"The Championship is a near £1bn league that cannot control its wage bill. It is a financial paradox, with record revenues across the league, unsustainable spending and yet a promotion race increasingly tilted towards the richest clubs."

The Leonard Curtis Football Finance Report comes as the EFL implements new Squad Cost Rules (SCR), with each club’s spending on player and manager-related costs, including transfer fees, limited to 85 per cent of its income.

Applying the new SCR retrospectively to 2024/25, the report’s analysis finds that 18 of 23 reporting clubs would have breached the 85% threshold, with 11 above 100 per cent.

When allowing for the maximum £16m owner equity injection permitted in one season under SCR, three clubs would have breached the limit (Burnley, Leeds United and Cardiff City).

Prof Rob Wilson, who is a professor of applied sport finance and co-author of the report, said: "While SCR should encourage clubs to live more closely within their means, because permitted spending is linked to revenue, higher-revenue clubs retain the ability to sustain much larger playing budgets.

"The rules may therefore improve sustainability without addressing the league’s competitive imbalance, with the Championship’s promotion race increasingly won in the balance sheet."

The findings also showed the dominance of clubs with recent spells in the Premier League, with last season’s relegated trio of West Ham (18.28m followers), Wolves (12.55m) and Burnley (3.83m) holding 48.6 per cent of the Championship’s following for 2026/27.

Prof Wilson said: "The findings point to significant untapped potential if clubs can combine compelling stories with younger, international audiences to build brand value far beyond what traditional football fundamentals would predict.

"For clubs, investors and commercial partners, that creates a major opportunity to rethink how digital reach is built, valued and monetised."

Women’s football is also explored in the report, with analysis of the challenges and opportunities created by the WSL2 (formerly the Women’s Championship) becoming fully professional in 2025/26.

Expert contributor Gessica Howarth – vice-president and a founding member of Sphera Partners, a growth equity investment firm with a key focus on women’s sport – said: "Five years ago the question was whether a professional second tier could exist in England at all.

"It now exists, sets attendance records, commands transfer fees and is attracting investors who sit on the boards of some of the largest sports franchises in the world.

"The flip side is that where a women’s team still lives inside a men’s club, it is in practice discretionary spend. Professional standards have raised the cost of competing faster than the revenues have arrived, and the honest answer is that someone has to fund that gap for long enough for the commercial base to catch up.

"Most women’s teams still have minimal dedicated commercial resource of their own, and that is where the upside is being left on the table."

LtoR: Report author Jonathan Dyson; co-author Prof. Rob Wilson; panel host James Cooper; Leonard Curtis CEO Dan Booth; foreword writer Matthew Jarvis; and Leonard Curtis director Alex Cadwallader.LtoR: Report author Jonathan Dyson; co-author Prof. Rob Wilson; panel host James Cooper; Leonard Curtis CEO Dan Booth; foreword writer Matthew Jarvis; and Leonard Curtis director Alex Cadwallader. (Image: LC)

The Leonard Curtis Football Finance Report also contains a message from Leonard Curtis CEO Dan Booth.

"The cost of running a football club in a billion-pound league is not for the faint-hearted. We see this play out in this report," he commented.

"The Championship is divided between ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’ in terms of revenue and the ability to spend on new players. While some have their sights set on the prize, others are simply trying to survive, and we can draw obvious parallels to owner-managed businesses currently fighting with everything they have got."

He added: "Like football, the business landscape is highly competitive. Companies must operate amid changing markets, rising costs, evolving technology and client expectations, while continuing to invest in their people and communities.

"A Championship football club is no different. Success never really comes from one individual or one moment. It is built through collective effort, strong foundations and the ability to make the right decisions."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos