How AI is helping SMEs recover lost revenue

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Julie Taylor faces a challenge that resonates across the UK’s SMEs and charities: payments slipping through the cracks.

As Head of Fundraising Operations at King’s College Hospital Charity, she has seen first-hand how funds intended to make a difference are often lost not through inefficiency but because of fragmented payment systems and operational silos.

“One of the biggest challenges is the spread of payments across multiple platforms,” Taylor explains.

“Our supporters pay using different online tools each with its own setup, processor and settlement timeline.”

Failed donations, lapsed mandates and unpredictable donor behaviour mean some payments succeed on one platform but fail on another while some recurring donors remain loyal for years and others disappear quickly.

This problem is not confined to charities. Across the SME sector, hidden revenue loss is increasingly common. Businesses often focus on transaction fees as the main cost of payments, overlooking the broader impact of failed payments, abandoned checkouts and payment-driven customer churn

Access PaySuite commissioned research among hundreds of UK SMEs to quantify the scale of the problem. The results were striking: 49% of respondents reported losing between £5,000 and £100,000 annually due to failed transactions, churn and the administrative burden of managing these issues.

Around 8% said they were losing more than £1 million annually. Notably, 95% of SMEs are now exploring AI-based systems as a way to uncover and recover hidden revenue.

Jon Reynolds, head of product at Access PaySuiteJon Reynolds, head of product at Access PaySuite (Image: Supplied)

An ecosystem built for leakage

The modern payments ecosystem is inherently complex. Authorisation failures, refunds, chargebacks, abandoned checkouts and silent churn are spread across multiple teams and dashboards, creating blind spots that few organisations can fully understand.

Tony Craddock, Director General of The Payments Association, describes the problem as “a whole series of typically quite small failures.” A minor decline rate may seem insignificant in isolation, but when multiplied across thousands of transactions the cumulative effect can be substantial.

Research from Access PaySuite shows that on average 3.4% of transactions fail and 55.8% of those failures are never recovered. Nearly half of businesses report checkout abandonment rates averaging 7.8% and more than one in five say customers switch to competitors for a smoother payment experience.

Sandra Mianda, Founder and CEO of Paypr.work, highlights that the issue is not only technical but cultural. “Payments have traditionally been seen as a cost centre,” she says. “KPIs track fees and approvals, but declines can happen for many reasons. There’s a real hidden opportunity in these failed transactions.”

For SMEs operating across multiple payment service providers, currencies and international markets, the complexity compounds. Data is often siloed across finance, product and customer service teams, making it difficult to detect patterns or intervene proactively.

The hidden cost of time

Lost revenue is only part of the picture. Many SMEs report spending five to 20 hours per week managing payment failures and the administrative overhead that comes with them.

Chris Jones, Managing Director of PSE Consulting, explains: “Small businesses are particularly affected by uncollected payments and the time spent reconciling across multiple systems. Consolidating these processes into a single workflow can be transformative.”

For charities, the operational impact can be even more acute. Taylor explains that failed donations require follow-ups, lapsed mandates and indemnity claims, all diverting staff from mission-critical work and reducing the overall efficiency of fundraising efforts.

The cumulative effect of these challenges is what industry experts call the ‘hidden revenue gap’: money that should be working for the business or charity but is instead lost due to process inefficiencies, fragmented infrastructure and siloed operations.

AI is turning data into insight

Against this backdrop, AI is emerging as a practical solution to both recover lost revenue and prevent future losses. David Birch, an international adviser on digital financial services, highlights AI’s ability to detect patterns and connections that human teams might miss. “Even small improvements in decline rates can have a significant financial impact,” he says.

Mianda emphasises that AI must go beyond simple automation. “Data alone isn’t enough,” she notes.

“The key is interpreting it in a way that informs actionable decisions. For payments, this might mean dynamically retrying a transaction, routing it differently or adjusting authentication triggers, all while staying fully compliant.”

Access PaySuite has embedded AI directly into its reporting dashboards, allowing finance and operations teams to interrogate data in natural language. Users can quickly identify which payments are failing, which customer segments are at risk of churn and how retry strategies are performing across providers. This shifts insight from quarterly reporting to real-time intervention, enabling businesses to act before losses occur.

Predictive modelling is particularly transformative for charities and subscription-based businesses.

Taylor notes: “If we can anticipate where payments might fail, we can act in advance to protect recurring donations. That means fewer lost contributions and more resources going to the people who need them.”

The broader potential of AI

Craddock sees opportunities beyond recovery. AI can be used to optimise user journeys, strengthen fraud prevention and even recover abandoned carts. Looking further ahead, programmability and micro-payments may reshape how value moves through the system, creating new revenue models and operational efficiencies.

However, experts caution that AI is not a silver bullet. Jones notes that AI-driven commerce may shift power toward platforms that control customer relationships. Businesses must remain mindful of data ownership and disintermediation risks as they leverage AI to generate incremental revenue.

From leakage to strategic advantage

The hidden revenue gap in UK SMEs is neither small nor inevitable. Payment failures, abandoned checkouts and churn collectively cost firms tens of thousands, sometimes millions, each year. Administrative burdens magnify the impact, consuming time and resources that could otherwise be directed toward growth or mission-critical work.

AI does not eliminate the structural quirks of legacy payments systems. What it does do is surface patterns, test interventions and automate recovery at scale, something no human team could achieve alone. For SMEs and charities alike, this translates into recovered revenue, reduced operational strain and more time to focus on strategic priorities.

Platforms are beginning to respond by embedding AI directly into payment platforms. Access PaySuite, for example, has developed a new unified payments platform with AI built in. Using AI to cut through raw data to surface meaningful insights, it brings payment data into a single view, freeing teams from specialist analysis, enabling immediate payment management and greater business value.

For Julie Taylor and organisations like hers, every failed donation is a lost opportunity to fund critical services. For SMEs, every failed subscription or abandoned cart impacts growth forecasts. By combining AI insights with proactive operational processes, businesses can turn previously hidden losses into actionable revenue opportunities, a shift that has the potential to reshape financial outcomes across the SME sector.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos