David Wright, founder of Fellpath Planning, speaks out about the regional planning system in Cumbria and why action is needed to stop the region "falling behind".
Planning in Cumbria is not just under pressure – it is close to paralysis. National policy talks confidently about delivering homes, supporting enterprise and driving sustainable growth, yet on the ground the system is increasingly incapable of turning aspiration into outcomes. No single person or organisation is to blame, but pretending the system is broadly working does Cumbria no favours.
The core problem is capacity. Local Planning Authorities in Cumbria are chronically under-resourced. I saw this starkly early in my career. When I left Copeland Borough Council in 2014, I was the sole Planning Enforcement Officer while also processing householder applications. I later moved to the Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea, where there were seven enforcement officers, ten in-house solicitors and entire teams dedicated to urban design, conservation and trees.
In Cumbria, one officer could spend an hour driving from Distington to Millom. In west London, six of us worked within four square miles. That imbalance has not narrowed; if anything, it has widened. Local government reform has reduced seven planning authorities to three, but so far has delivered little improvement in frontline capacity.
Also on in-Cumbria:
-
'We can't afford to fail': BEC and the mission to bring £12bn to West Cumbria
-
Cumbria's visitor economy businesses invited to customer service courses
-
ANDY BEEFORTH OBE: What do we want from Cumbria's combined authority?
-
'Tourism tax will have disastrous consequences for Cumbria': Holiday park chief
Meanwhile, experienced officers are retiring, taking irreplaceable local knowledge with them, while councils increasingly rely on short-term contract planners making high-stakes decisions from outside the communities affected.
Nutrient neutrality then took a fragile system and pushed it to breaking point. From early 2022, planning in large parts of Cumbria effectively stopped.
David Wright on site (Image: Supplied)
While river pollution is a serious issue, new development accounts for a tiny fraction of the problem. Yet thousands of homes were stalled overnight because no strategic solution existed. The damage to housing delivery, confidence and investment has been profound and largely avoidable.
Layered on top is a national planning framework that talks up flexibility but in practice rewards paperwork over judgement.
Out-of-date local plans, endless five-year housing land supply arguments and ever-expanding validation requirements mean decisions increasingly hinge on technical compliance rather than whether development is genuinely sustainable or needed.
For SMEs and first-time applicants, the message is clear: planning is something to be endured, not enabled. Cumbria’s next generation of home-grown success stories risk never getting started.
Despite this, Cumbria remains full of opportunity. At Fellpath Planning, we help clients navigate a system that too often feels designed to obstruct rather than support. But if Cumbria is serious about retaining its working-age population, delivering homes and building a resilient economy, it needs a planning system that is properly resourced, proportionate and confident enough to say “yes” as well as “no”.
Without that shift, ambition will remain stuck on paper – and Cumbria will continue to fall behind.
Share