The long-awaited review into farm profitability has renewed calls for a rethink on inheritance tax and clarity on nature-friendly farming schemes.
The farm profitability report by former National Farmers’ Union president Baroness Minette Batters has called for a “new deal for profitable farming” that recognises the true cost of producing food and delivering for the environment.
Baroness Batters said the change to levy inheritance tax on farm businesses worth more than £1 million was the single biggest issue raised by respondents in relation to farming viability, although it lay outside the terms of reference for the review.
Uncertainty over the sustainable farming incentive scheme – which forms the main part of the post-Brexit environmental land management scheme (Elms) for agricultural payments – was also an ongoing concern.
The review calls for a new deal for farming between Government and industry, with a long-term plan that increases demand for British produce, boosts farming incomes, productivity and resilience, makes supply chains fair, and values nature, wildlife and water quality.
In response to the review, Liberal Democrat environment, food and rural affairs spokesman Tim Farron said: “This devastating review, commissioned by the Government, must be the final nail in the coffin for the hated family farm tax.
“Minette Batters has found that the family farm tax could threaten the viability of British farms.
“Labour MPs must now vote with their conscience and vote to scrap the family farm tax in the new year.”
Shadow environment secretary Victoria Atkins said that Baroness Batters’ report found the farming sector “is ‘bewildered and frightened of what might lay ahead’ because of the vindictive family farm and family business taxes”.
She said: “Instead of dealing with ‘the single biggest issue’ facing the industry, the Government’s only response today is to create yet another quango – the very last thing that farmers need,” as she said only the Tories would stand up for rural communities, axe the tax and cut bureaucracy.
Also on in-Cumbria
But Chancellor Rachel Reeves told broadcasters during a visit to a north London community centre that the changes around inheritance tax were “fair”.
“The changes around inheritance tax mean that if you are a couple with far more than £3 million in value, you will pay inheritance tax, but it will be at 20% rather than the usual rate of 40% and it will be repayable over 10 years interest free, which is something that no other estates are able to benefit from.
“I think that is a fair change, because we are asking people with those substantial assets to make a contribution to fund the public services like our NHS that we all rely on,” she said.
National Farmers’ Union president Tom Bradshaw backed Defra’s priorities for delivering on the review, on supply chain fairness, planning reforms, growing exports, creating a new farming and food partnership board, and tackling barriers to private finance streams.
But he said: “Alongside this, there are other immediate actions that are needed to boost British farming, like providing much-needed clarity and certainty on the future of the sustainable farming incentive and doing the right thing on the pernicious inheritance tax changes.
“Secretary of State Emma Reynolds recently said that farm profitability was vital to enable the UK agriculture sector to grow. We couldn’t agree more.
“The NFU stands ready to work with Government to deliver our collective ambitions for economic growth delivered by a British agriculture sector that is set up to thrive.”
Country Land and Business Association president Gavin Lane said the report highlighted how profitability in the sector was “perilously slim” in the face of high cost, low commodity prices and volatile weather.
“Many farm businesses are marginal or loss-making, yet will soon be hit with unaffordable inheritance tax bills, which in many cases will dwarf their annual profit.
“Now is the time for urgent action.
“We need a stable policy environment, clarity on farming schemes, real planning reform, and a recognition that a joined-up approach to rural affairs is desperately needed across Government.”
Vicki Hird, strategic lead for agriculture at The Wildlife Trusts, warned restoring nature across the farmed landscape was not just a “nice to have, it’s a critical part of future-proofing farm businesses and underpins farmers’ ability to produce food”.
She said: “The Government must urgently get the environmental land management schemes back on track so that they support farmers to build more resilient, nature-friendly businesses which are fit for the future.”
Sofia Parente from conservation charity WWF said: “A strong, profitable domestic farming sector only contributes to food security when it also protects and enhances the natural capital which sustains food production: a stable climate, healthy soils, clean rivers and abundant wildlife.
“Climate change and nature loss are driving an unprecedented threat to food security, and so it is disappointing there is so little emphasis on this crucial point at a time when farmers are experiencing financial losses due to extreme weather events worsened by climate change and nature loss.”
She said she was concerned that Defra’s initial response, to create a farming and food partnership board, was envisaged without environmental expertise.
“As Defra takes forward plans for a 25-year farming road map, we hope for stronger engagement from the Government with farmers and environment experts to ensure a profitable farming sector delivers for climate, nature and the nutrition security of the nation,” she said.
Share