Chancellor Rachel Reeves had promised to make "fair and necessary" choices in her Autumn Budget this year, suggesting that her policies would ultimately benefit business as well as individuals and the wider country. She met with companies to listen to their concerns and emphasised that the government wanted to "help small businesses."
Still, these assurances did little to lift the pessimistic mood among businesses in Cumbria, many of whom were unconvinced by the Chancellor's ability - or resource - to produce an economic plan that would ease the pressure. Some admitted that they were deeply worried.
Once the statement was over - delivered in a 'bullish' manner, as one commentator described - there was no mass outpouring of anger from Cumbia companies, but no huge sighs of relief, either.
Leaked online before Reeves even had the opportunity to tell the House of Commons what was in it, the Budget offered a hodgepodge of policies: A freeze of income tax and National Insurance thresholds until April 2031; a high-value council tax surcharge on properties worth over £2 million (with even higher rates for properties worth over £5 million); a 5p cut in fuel duty until September 2026, higher taxes on dividends, savings and property income; and lower permanent business rates for 750,000 retail, hospitality and leisure properties.
It was a mixed bag, and in this feature, we go over the big business takeaways of the Budget - asking local leaders in Cumbria for their verdicts on what Reeves presented.
The leak and OBR: 'Uncertainty when stability was needed'
Brett Bennett (Image: Supplied)
Whilst The Chancellor had clearly attempted to build a Budget that would appease as many as possible - all the while "ensuring the wealthy contributed the most" - her statement was immediately undermined when the plans were leaked online in what the OBR called a "technical error" and Kemi Badenoch called a "circus".
Tax partner at leading Cumbrian accountants, robinson+co, Brett Bennett, said it was "deeply concerning".
"Not only has [the leak] overshadowed the substance of the Budget, but it risks undermining market confidence in the fiscal process itself," he stated.
"For advisers and taxpayers, it creates uncertainty at precisely the moment when stability is most needed.”
Professor Joe Nellis, economic adviser at Kendal firm MHA, said there was also a "big question mark" over whether the Budget would produce the growth the Chancellor predicted and promised.
He stated: "Has the Budget actually helped put money in people’s pockets in the short-term? Not really.
"The freeze on income tax and National Insurance thresholds until 2028 will drag many earners into paying higher rates of tax, and the above-inflation increase in the minimum wage could disincentivise hiring at a time of high youth unemployment and economic activity.
"Movement towards fiscal stability was unclear. The financial markets appear content - increased tax revenues by £26bn has given the Chancellor a more comfortable fiscal headroom of £20bn - but the OBR and Treasury disagree on whether debt as a share of GDP will be on its way down by 2030."
Also on in-Cumbria: Rachel Reeves announces salary sacrifice changes in Budget | In Cumbria
The big picture for business: 'Fairly unscathed' but still 'major pressure'
Dominic Thackray (Image: Supplied)
Some businesses say the Budget could have been significantly worse than it turned out, but there remains a degree of frustration among the community nonetheless.
Cumbria accountancy Lamont Pridmore said that "businesses appear to have gotten away fairly unscathed in this year’s Budget in contrast to the announcements in 2024," but business owners will still face a "major pressure" due to the additional rise in National Minimum Wage and the National Living Wage due in April 2026.
John Stevenson, Managing Partner at Cumbrian law firm Bendles Solicitors, also said there was a "lack of support" offered by in the statement that would have helped to stimulate market growth.
“Businesses owners and leaders are operating in an increasingly challenging environment and it would have been helpful if Budget had included more support to encourage growth and development," he stated.
Other businessowners admitted they will need to "cut running costs and put prices up" as a result of the Budget. Joanne Stronach, MD at Cartmell Shepherd, said the statement "will compel many businesses to review workforce plans and pricing strategies."
Dominic Thackray, Independent Financial Adviser at MHA, noted the tax raise on savings, dividends and property income would be a burden in particular.
"Reeves anticipates this won’t impact 90% of people, but it will impact the holiday-let industry, landlords, investors and business owners," he said.
"The rental market serves a purpose, holiday lets drive local tourism and investors and business owners will be discouraged from taking risk.
"For those investors that are looking to best navigate these tax changes – funds in ISAs, still at £20,000 contributed a year, pay no tax on profits, and above the allowance there are ways in which tax on investment profits can be deferred to a later date (where tax may be lower), or onto another individual that has a lower marginal rate of tax."
Ms Stronach called the Budget a "double-edged sword".
"A number of positive changes included lower business rates for over 750,000 retail, hospitality and leisure properties; funding for planners, and free training for people under-25 on apprenticeships for SMEs.
"However, many businesses, particularly those with large workforces, will be concerned about the planned uplift in the national living and minimum wages. These rises often have a knock-on effect, as the salaries of more senior staff are adjusted, thereby increasing wage costs further.
"While the uplift offers a boost for lower paid workers, the resulting impact could discourage investment and recruitment."
Also on in-Cumbria: 'Cash Isa limit cut to £12,000 may not encourage investment | In Cumbria'
Inheritance tax: 'Farmers have campaigned relentlessly'
John Stevenson, Managing Partner, Bendles Solicitors (Image: Supplied)
Inheritance Tax has also been a source of frustration in the agricultural sector. On the morning of the Budget, farmers steered a convoy of tractors into Westminster to protest changes around agricultural property relief.
John Stevenson at Bendles Solicitors said that the Chancellor did not go far enough to reduce the impact of these upcoming changes to inheritance tax rules for family businesses and farmers, which are due to take effect in April 2026.
He stated: "The announcement that the £1 million threshold is now transferable between spouses will be of little consolation to those concerned about the long-term future of their businesses.
“For the past 12 months, the farming community and business organisations have campaigned relentlessly against these changes, highlighting the potentially devastating impact they will have on family businesses and farms.
“The changes to inheritance tax are particularly significant for Cumbria where we have such a strong agricultural sector.
"For farmers and family businesses, the best course of action from a legal perspective is to plan ahead and make sure they have a clear strategy in place for the future.”
Also on in-Cumbria: Rachel Reeves scraps two-child benefit cap in Budget | In Cumbria
The mansion tax: 'For some... property is their pension'
Richard Bond (Image: Supplied)
Some businesses have also expressed dismay at the added taxes for landlords and properties.
Rachael Bell, Practice Principal at Rachael Bell Wealth Management, claimed the Budget "hits wealth built on property squarely between the eyes".
She stated: "There’s no dressing it up: this Budget penalises those who’ve built their wealth through assets.
"The appeal of relying solely on investments or property for income has been eroded. Now’s the moment to take stock - and rebalance portfolios with a sharp eye on how taxable income will be treated in the years ahead."
Richard Bond, founder of holiday cottage agency Finest Retreats, said these taxes are going to hit people who are "asset rich but cash poor" - pointing out that for some property owners, this is "their only pension."
"There's an extra 2% on income tax for landlords, and fact that corporate holders of property won't be affected by that means it's a bit of an unlevel playing field," he stated.
"So it might encourage a few more people to tip the balance and encourage them to switch over to a limited company structure instead, but that comes with extra stamp duty costs.
"If your pension is in property and you've saved your whole life and put it into property, then obviously you'll be badly affected by the mansion tax.
"It's expensive running these big properties and it's easy to assume that they belong to wealthy land-owning gentry when the reality is they probably inherited it. They've got this big house that's expensive to run. So, they'll probably just be looking at ways of diversifying more or putting up prices and reacting in that way."
The next chapter: 'Businessowners are a resilient bunch'
Chris Brown (Image: Supplied)
Despite the disappointment that greeted portions of the Budget, Cumbria business owners have also expressed a degree of satisfaction now the statement is done.
A recent Barclays report showed that almost half of businesses had paused investment until the Budget was announced, and whilst the economic plan did not necessarily prove to be wholly good news for business, it does offer a clearer idea of what to expect in the coming years so they can plan accordingly.
Chris Brown, Managing Director of Kendal-based Brown & Co accountants, says that businesses across Cumbria had been looking for a Budget that “gives them the space to get on with what they do best.”
He stated: “Business owners and entrepreneurs are a resilient bunch – they always find a way through. Cumbrian firms have a knack for adapting and cracking on."
Mr Bond of Finest Retreats added: "All sorts of trades have been affected over the past three months and whenever there's more tax and regulation and just it makes people worried, they stop investing.
"So, for businesses like ours, it just means you don't end up doing the renovation, you don't end up spending more money fixing prices problems. You sort of like limp along and patch it over.
"If you're running a business, you just want to be sort of left to get on with it and you don't want sleepless nights because that does paralyse you."
Share