Feeling the squeeze: When will milk prices recover?

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Can plummeting milk prices recover? Robert Craig, Chair of the Royal Association of British Dairy Farmers (RABDF) says it could be some time.

Following 12 months of reasonable stability, dairy commodity markets seem to have gone into freefall feeding through to farmgate prices falling steeply to around 35ppl, levels many producers haven’t seen since autumn 2023.

Milk prices steadily climbed throughout 2024 stabilising towards the end of the year with the standard manufacturing litre returning around 45 ppl.

As dairy farmers we’ve got used to fairly extreme market volatility over the past few years with previous cycles following the seasonal norm of prices either stable or falling during the peak supply months, rising later in the year when supply is at it lowest. For commodity prices to be falling so steeply, now, through the low production months, it suggests different market dynamics than in previous cycles.

To better understand we need to look at several factors which have led to the current over supply of milk in the past 12 months. The economics needed for production growth are currently and have been, favourable across all major dairy producing countries for around 12 months.

In the UK, even with much of the country suffering from a drought in 2025, we’ve seen the purchased feed to milk price ratio, (a useful indicator for supply growth or decline) driving supply growth of between 2 per cent to 6 per cent every month for almost last year.

Although cow numbers across the EU are steadily falling, problems resulting from the Bluetongue virus, widespread in the EU throughout 2024, are no longer holding back production. Now it appears that poor fertility connected with the virus, has changed the seasonal calving and production pattern in mainland Europe, resulting in milk production growth of around 4 per cent as production is pushed back towards the end of 2025. Similar in New Zealand production is also rising and is around 4 per cent higher than last season, partly due to expected environmental regulation having less impact and the record payout/margins resulting from the 2024/25 season.

Significant recent investment in the US, mainly in cheese production has driven production growth in the states and has seen the US dairy herd growing by almost 200,000 cows or 2.1 per cent the largest increase for 25 years. All of these factors are contributing to the current global over supply of milk, leading to the collapse in dairy commodities.

Global dairy product demand is however still strong, although it’s just not growing at the same pace of supply. The continued over-supply and the resulting build of stocks will prolong the bearish market.

It’s likely that even after production falls back closer to demand but eventually the market signals resulting from the oversupply of milk will lead to a reduction in supply.

The disease risk of bluetongue is still very real and could again impact future milk production across the EU.

Milk prices may not stabilise for some time (Image: Supplied)

A new threat, also being spread by biting insects is Lumpy skin disease which could also reduce EU milk production with cases now confirmed in Italy and France.

Weather is also a continual uncertainty, although currently milk production in NZ is strong, a drought or even very wet grazing conditions before the year end could have a significant effect on grass production and utilisation which in turn would reduce milk production.

It’s very difficult to call the bottom of the market or predict how low prices may go, it’s even more difficult to make any predictions of when producer prices will improve.

On a positive note, low prices will drive demand as dairy become cheaper and becomes more competitive, bearing in mind the current growing stocks were largely made with relatively expensive milk and will need to be sold before markets return to balance.

Another factor is that cull cow volumes are below historic norms even though values are high, with the shortage of forage being a real concern for many parts of the UK, a surge in culling numbers and a significant reduction in milk supply could see milk prices recover sooner than expected.

Unfortunately, it’s more likely to take at least 12 months before we see producer prices back to where they were a few months ago.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos