Architects call car park recommendation 'indefensible'

An artist impression of the car park <i>(Image: Crosby Granger Architects)</i>
An artist impression of the car park (Image: Crosby Granger Architects)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A planning officer's recommendation to refuse a new car park at Ullock Moss has been criticised as "indefensible" by applicants.

Lingholm Private Trust’s proposal to "ease serious highway hazards" on the Portinscale to Cat Bells route involved a 150-space car park at Ullock Moss with a toilet block and a turning facility for a shuttle bus service.

Lingholm and its agents have now expressed frustration at the recommendation to block their plans - which have been in discussion for five years.

They have vowed to appeal the decision if it is taken.

A CGI image of a car park with modern-looking amenity buildings in the English Lake District An artist's impression of the proposed car park at Ullock Moss (Image: Crosby Granger Architects)

Officers of the Lake District National Park Authority will recommend that the planning application is refused on the grounds that the development would "cause harm to the character and appearance of the area."

READ MORE: Catbells car park near Portinscale statement

A case officer also determined that the plans do not meet one of the park authority's rigorous transport policies as it would not "resolve an unacceptable highway safety issue or hazard."

A service bus blocked on its route by cars parked at the roadside. (Image: Supplied)

READ MORE: Businessman's 'solution' to parking issues near Keswick

The applicant, Lingholm Private Trust, believes the decision would ignore "clear professional evidence of risk," revealed by an independent road safety assessment carried-out last year.

Nicholson Sloan Consultancy's assessment in 2024 identified a number of danger points where pedestrians are forced to walk in live traffic to get around cars parked at the roadside.

Inconsiderate parking was also found to be blocking emergency service vehicles and buses.

Chris Granger, Managing Director of Crosby Granger Architects said: "The officer’s report contains assumptions that are demonstrably incorrect and conclusions that cannot withstand scrutiny.

"Those errors will now be used as the basis of an appeal which will test, line by line, the accuracy and veracity of the officer’s claims"

READ MORE: Villagers furore over 'Cat Bells car park

He called the officer's view that the plans would not mitigate roads safety issues "indefensible."

Enforcement notices on a number of vehicles incorrectly parked in Portinscale this weekend. (Image: Intro PR)

Mr Granger said: "The evidence is there in the record, in photographs, and in the hundreds of enforcement notices issued every year.

"Cumbria Highways cited safety issues as the justification for introducing double yellow lines. They haven’t worked and to suggest the problem has gone away is not professional judgement – it is a dangerous misrepresentation of fact."

Similar plans were refused by the planning committee in 2021 and a subsequent application in 2022 was withdrawn prior to a decision being made.

Although the case officer is recommending that the application is refused, elected members of the national park will make the final decision on whether or not to grant planning permission.

Wayfaring House at Murley Moss in Kendal, where the decision will be taken (Image: Lake District National Park Authority)

The meeting takes place at 10am on November 5 at Murley Moss in Kendal.

Members of the public are welcome to attend the meeting in-person, or watch the livestream on the Lake District National Park YouTube page.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos