Julia Aglionby, executive director, Foundation for Common Land, reflects on the past year for the charity
The last 12 months have been a time of mixed emotion for commoners, common landowners and all those working passionately to deliver more in the uplands for landscape, nature, climate and sustainable food.
As I write many of us feel somewhat discombobulated by the uncertainty in the wider world. Closer to home in the nerdy world of agricultural policy farmers and advisors stare into a chasm as one scheme after another goes up in smoke. Meanwhile Defra continues apace with policy wonkery; consultations on Land Use Framework, Nature Finance Regulations and the 25-year Farming Road map all under way. Yes, these are all important topics, but will our input deliver change on the ground to help farmers manage land better?
So what does all this mean for commons? And what have we at the Foundation for Common Land been doing over the last 12 months. As Whitehall edicts become ever more fantastical my advice to myself is to ‘stick to the knitting’. How and where can we as a small charity have the greatest impact to improve outcomes from common land and commoning?
‘Our Upland Commons’, a 24 partner English wide project, is after seven years drawing to a close of its five-year delivery phase thanks to funding from National Lottery Players and many other local partners including Cumbria Wildlife Trust, Federation of Cumbria Commoners, the National Trust and the Lake District Foundation.
We have learnt so much and been delighted to work closely with Cumbria’s commoners on bracken management, natural flood management, farmer led habitat assessment, carbon toolkits, improving access to name but a few of our projects. Thank you to all who have given their time, money and skills. We have recently had the exciting news that the Lottery have granted the Foundation for Common Land some additional funding for two years to build capacity so in the future we can support more commoners and outcomes from common land.
(Image: Foundation for Common Land)
One Defra scheme that was working well – until stopped in March 2025 with no notice - was the Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) Moorland Survey. This provided an opportunity for farmers to be paid to collect data on the state of soils and nature of vegetation on their common. To empower and enable commoners and other moorland managers to access this scheme we designed a phone app to take you to your randomly assigned points on the moor and collect the necessary data.
This year 150,000 hectares of moorland signed up to use the Foundation for Common Land’s SFI Moorland App service. With the app we have helped moorland farmers access over £2 million of funding each year. As importantly, farmers are learning about what their land is delivering for nature, climate and soils. Fortunately those already in the scheme have a couple more years in their agreements and we hope SFI will reopen in 2026.
‘Our Upland Commons’ piggy backed on the SFI App to enable commoners to collect ecological habitat data including condition assessments on Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSIs). The majority of common land in Cumbria is designated for nature as SSSIs and Special Areas of Conservation (SACs). Natural England aim to assess SSSIs every six years but funding constraints mean the gap between assessments is often longer.
Using funds from Our Upland Commons and working with Derwent Commoners, The Farmer Network and H&H Land and Estates we developed our SFI Moorland Survey to ask additional questions about the seven different moorland habitats. Commoners were already travelling to one point every 10 ha on their common for the SFI Survey so the extra time involved was very limited.
As part of the project farmers were trained to identify valuable habitats such as valley flushes and mires, montane habitats and upland heath and then assess the condition. A practical waterproof pictural guide was produced taking commoners through a step by step flow chart process to differentiate different habitats. They were then recorded on the app. No phone signal is required and the data is synced when you later have internet access. This information can then be shared with Natural England to negotiate appropriate stocking levels for stewardship agreements.
A key part of Our Upland Commons has been creating bridges of learning and connections between different areas of commons across England. We have developed a series of informative webinars that can be accessed on our YouTube channel on topics as wide ranging as Trees on Commons to Animal Health and Cultural Heritage. We also have digital training resources and guides on our website. We also reach out to the public through our ‘Common Stories’ developed by Cumbrian artists Harriet and Rob Fraser, of Somewhere Nowhere telling the story of commoning in words, pictures and videos.
What has been a most interesting development this last year has been the development of Landscape Recovery Schemes. This upper tier of Environmental Land Management (ELM) is ambitious and also lasts 20 years with index linked payments. FCL in 2022 and 2023 explored the potential for Landscape Recovery through our Defra funded Test & Trial in the New Forest and Malvern Hills.
We are now bringing that learning to Cumbria to assist the West Cumbria Rivers Trust develop the Resilient Glenderamackin scheme. This catchment includes Matterdale, Threlkeld and Mungrisdale Commons. No decision has yet been made but these commons recognise that delivering for nature, climate and flood resilience can underpin their livestock businesses especially on SSSI designated sites. Having been trapped in stewardship schemes whose payment rates haven’t increased since 2005 an index linked scheme seems a fairer approach going forward. Also when government finance seems somewhat flaky then a long term 20 year commitment is an unusual opportunity. Questions remain - do we have enough skilled people to do the fencing and maintain woodlands in these challenging locations?
This year and next will be a period of both consolidation and new opportunities for the Foundation for Common Land. We hold onto our key learning that delivering more for nature, climate and landscape only happens on the foundation stones of strong trust between the many parties involved on commons and relies on financially viable thriving farm businesses.
Share