Student’s career dream in tatters after street attack
Last updated at 13:33, Monday, 14 January 2013
A university student saw her future in tatters after kicking a woman in the face.
Georgia Winter, 20, had hoped for a career in the probation service but a judge at Carlisle Crown Court told her she had little hope of that now that she had a criminal conviction for violence.
Winter – who handed the court a sheaf of character references including one from Lord Bragg and other leading figures in the Wigton area – nodded as Recorder Kevin Grice said her appearance in the dock had been an “absolute catastrophe” for her.
“The fact that you got involved in all this remains incredible to those who know you,” he said.
“You are otherwise a hard-working, decent young woman who had a very promising career ahead of her.
“I hope that your career will still have promise, but it may well be that this conviction will blight it. That could be your greatest punishment.”
Prosecuting counsel Mark Lamberty told the court Winter had been walking down an arcade with Carl Filby, 19, when he spat in the face of previous girlfriend Isla Kennedy who was coming the other way.
Filby walked on – “in cowardly fashion,” the judge said – but Ms Kennedy grabbed Winter by the hair and they ended up on the ground.
Winter kicked her once “very hard” in the face, leaving her with a broken nose which has already required one operation and will need another next month.
Winter, whose address was listed as St Andrews Gardens, Liverpool, where she is in her second year at university, pleaded guilty to a charge of unlawful wounding.
In mitigation, defence barrister Erimnaz Mushtaq said Winter had not started the violence.
Ms Mushtaq said Winter came from a respectable family who could not believe what she had done.
“She can’t believe it either,” she said. She said she now had “no hope” of pursuing her dream of working in the probation service, and had already given up a work placement for which she had been one of six students ‘handpicked’.
Winter was given a 10-month prison sentence, suspended for 18 months, and ordered to do 150 hours unpaid community work.
Filby, of Webster Crescent, Carlisle, pleaded guilty to common assault on Ms Kennedy by spitting at her.
He was ordered to do 100 hours unpaid community work and pay £100 compensation to his ex-girlfriend.
First published at 13:31, Monday, 14 January 2013
Published by http://www.newsandstar.co.uk
Editor's picks
- NDA boss hits out at slow Sellafield progress
- Firm keeps La’al Ratty on track
- Revealed: Schedule for roll-out of superfast broadband in Cumbria (5 comments)
- MP 'incredibly angry' at broadband roll-out plans
- New Allerdale boss makes jobs his top priority
- New Allerdale boss makes jobs his top priority
- Funniest Apprentice Tweets: Episode 7, Series 9
- Made in Cumbria: Dizzee Rascal's new website
- Carr's Milling buys up US firm
- Tata Steel reveals heavy losses
More news
- Booths is applauded for ethical approach
- Wigton's top apprentices meet Vince Cable at Westminster
- Deadline for free training courses in Carlisle
- £7m construction skills centre opening in west Cumbria
- Pit your company against Cumbria’s finest
- Fixed fees - the modern way
- Barrow man’s mission is to give customers a great time
BBC News business headlines
in-cumbria features
- Fixed fees - the modern way
- Barrow man’s mission is to give customers a great time
- Fighting for broadband
- Take the stress out of change
- Ulverston hairdresser is cut above
- Barrow team reveals how firms are helping boost pupils’ skills
- Pupils in driving seat at Furness College open day
- Be wary of Pig campaign idea
- Meaty types hold prices at Ulverston Auction Mart
- Tenders invited for social housing work in Cumbria
- Health secretary Jeremy Hunt makes statement on failure to investigate trust behind Barrow hospital
- Ulverston firefighters free child from locked car
- Barrow hospital scandal 'deeply disturbing' – prime minister (2 comments)
- September decision on whether Americans will continue to run Sellafield
- Cafe opens in Carlisle's first LGBT headquarters
- Carlisle man admits having loaded air weapon in public
- Man who stole from deaf Carlisle OAP wins first stage of sentence appeal
- Cumbria police pledge crackdown on illegal sale of weapons
- BBC DIY SOS appeals for help with Cumbrian tot's house revamp
- Carlisle-Cockermouth A595 roadworks boost for drivers




Investment to increase capacity at Carlisle’s Lanes shopping centre is on the cards following a change of ownership.
What brought one of the most advanced performance management systems to Cumbria?
Cumbria business women make waves on the west coast