Cumbrian tycoon ‘not in the loop’ on kickbacks, court told
Last updated at 12:15, Wednesday, 05 December 2012
A wealthy businessman would have stopped kickbacks being paid to a foreign bank boss if he had known about them, a court heard.
Related: Accused Cumbrian tycoon was just being ‘helpful’, court told
Former Innovia boss Bill Lowther, 73, is accused of bribing Vietnam's state bank boss Le Duc Thuy by paying for his son to study an MBA at Durham University.
The packaging magnate, from Carlisle, admits lining up an interview with an academic at the institution but denies knowing some £21,000 was also spent on the student's tuition and living costs.
Prosecutors allege Lowther hoped the move would ensure a lucrative deal to make banknotes for the southeast Asian country.
But the tycoon's lawyer, Alexander Cameron QC – older brother of Prime Minister David – argued his client was abroad without internet access or a fax machine when the details were discussed by email.
He said: “When these emails arrive, and are printed off and put on his desk, he’s in Spain – he doesn't actually see it.
“If he's one of the conspirators and he's in on this, why isn't he part of this little email?
“We suggest he had done his bit: get the guy an interview. That was what he'd done, and that was where it ended as far as he was concerned.
Mr Cameron added: “Mr Lowther is not in on this.
“The rest of it, the corrupt bit, isn't happening with him. Had it, he would have put a stop to it.”
Jurors earlier heard Lowther personally drove Minh from the airport to his interview at Durham University, as well as helping arrange the alleged corruption by paying his fees and accommodation.
The allegation relates to a period between January 1 and December 31, 2003.
Harvard-educated Lowther has racked up a string of honours during a career spanning four decades, including an OBE, CBE and honorary knighthood from the King of Belgium.
He started his career in 1970 with manufacturing firm OPP and eventually became UK managing director.
In 1990, Lowther became director general of worldwide operations, with responsibility for 2,900 employees and a turnover of £424 million.
He took semi-retirement in 2002, but remained as director of the firm until he resigned in October last year, shortly after he was charged with the Serious Fraud Office.
Speaking from the witness box, he earlier told the court arranging the interview was of 'no importance' to winning the Vietnamese contract.
“'If I am asked to help a young person, I see this as kind of piffling,' he said.
“We help dozens of young people.”
The trial continues.
First published at 12:14, Wednesday, 05 December 2012
Published by http://www.newsandstar.co.uk
Editor's picks
- Cumbria's superfast broadband delayed by EU red tape again
- Pirelli factory death probe ordered tougher safety measures
- Dangerous machines among H&S offences in Carlisle area
- Slurry lagoons and asthma causing chemicals among Eden safety issues
- Factory heat could be used to warm 30,000 Cumbrian homes
- Businesses urged to get behind university's new business school
- Cumbria sets up links with Chinese university
- Patchy broadband damaging rural businesses (4 comments)
- £4m fund launched to help Cumbrian firms
- City predicts parts of Stobart Group will be sold
More news
- Stobart Group boss hopes for flights from Carlisle next summer
- Cumbria LEP seeks commission members
- Profits down at Jennings Brothers owner
- Awards commendation for Cumbrian insulation invention
- Number of unemployed falls in Cumbria
- Underlying profits up but Stobart Group takes hit on pallet operation
- Sellafield has need for up to £100m worth of steel boxes
BBC News business headlines
in-cumbria features
- Fish factory axes 40 jobs after loss of key contract
- Don’t smash your caravan - sell to me!
- Revamp for Maryport Post Office
- Fashion designer starts gem of an online business
- More than 1,000 clamour to climb in Maryport
- Stobart Group aiming to start flights to Carlisle Airport as profits rise
- Awards commendation for Cumbrian insulation invention
- Number of unemployed falls in Cumbria
- Underlying profits up but Stobart Group takes hit on pallet operation
- Sellafield has need for up to £100m worth of steel boxes
- Hunt for Millom men after car torched in street
- Cumbrian planners unable to stop influx of windfarms
- Cumbrian big cat had been spotted before - claim
- Cumbria police took DNA from almost 600 youngsters under 18
- Cumbrian man climbed through bathroom window to get to estranged wife
- Police pledge crackdown on Carlisle estate
- Lucky escapes after pile-up on A66 in Cumbria
- Cumbrian family's plea for details about missing pet dog
- Homecoming Parade gets under way
- Go-ahead for superfast broadband roll-out across Cumbria (2 comments)




Investment to increase capacity at Carlisle’s Lanes shopping centre is on the cards following a change of ownership.
What brought one of the most advanced performance management systems to Cumbria?
Cumbria business women make waves on the west coast