Cumbrian brothers cleared of 'dragged from car' robbery
Last updated at 13:22, Friday, 09 November 2012
Two brothers have been cleared of robbing a man after a week long trial.
Russell Roberts, 29, and Jonathan Roberts, 34, had both denied robbing Jonathan Nichols, who said he was dragged from his VW Golf car in Clayton Avenue, Cleator Moor, on May 3 last year.
Russell Roberts, of Dent Place, Cleator Moor, and Jonathan Roberts, of Gillfoot Road, Egremont, admitted they were in the general area of Cleator Moor but denied any involvement in a robbery.
They were cleared by the jury yesterday afternoon.
Earlier in the week, Mr Nicholson was accused in court of falsely accusing the brothers because he was a drug dealer and owed money by one of them.
Defence barrister David Birrell accused him of making a false allegation because he was owed £600.
Mr Birrell accused Mr Nicholson of making the whole story up.
He questioned how there were no witnesses to the alleged robbery, even though it happened on a busy street on a sunny Bank Holiday. And he asked how Mr Nicholson, though unemployed for several years, managed to be driving a decent car.
“It’s because you make money selling drugs, don’t you?” he said. “You are a drug dealer. You sell cannabis and what is known as plant food.”
Mr Nicholson said that was not true, although he admitted police had spoken to him in the past about drug dealing.
Mr Birrell said Russell Roberts owed Mr Nicholson £600.
“He had owed you money for some time, hadn’t he? And that angered you,” said Mr Birrell.
“No,” Mr Nicholson replied.
First published at 11:52, Friday, 09 November 2012
Published by http://www.newsandstar.co.uk
- Should firms support Labour's minimum wage plans?
- Cumbrian businesses refute office space claims
- New Balance Cumbria is 'factory of the future'
- The £7 million semi-detached home in Carlisle?
- Carlisle Living Awards: winners revealed
- Movers and shakers in the Cumbrian business world
- Chef to hold masterclasses for food business start-ups
- Foreign visitors to Lake District on the rise
- Cumbrian village digs its own broadband network
- Story Homes submits plan for 190 houses in north Carlisle (46 comments)
- Record occupancy for Cumbria hotel
- New map shows details of proposed power lines route across Cumbria (10 comments)
- SMEs lose out in council spending
- Stobart Group upbeat about latest results
BBC News business headlines
- Wedding planning duo have ring of confidence
- Benefits of wind power
- Good things come in threes for top accountants
- Apprentice schemes prove popular with school leavers
- Perfect chance to make your leadership dreams come true
- Glenn and Julie had the bottle to go it alone with plastics firm
- Dedication looks set to pay off for an ‘inspirational’ young apprentice
- Pupils compete for chance to quiz companies
- Businesswoman in line for top award
- Mules proved to be just champion at Gimmer lambs annual sale
- Carlisle scaffolding drama
- Appeal after smashed trailer light in Barrow
- Ulverston man, 81, who fell through roof is "very lucky to be alive" - say family
- Cumbria road closure after collision
- Tributes paid to 'one-of-a-kind' Carlisle dad
- Ulverston supermarket row set for legal showdown in court
- Road closed after one-car crash
- Road closed after car accident
- Barrow pet owner’s heartbreak after beloved cat is killed
- HGV and driving instructor's car collide on busy Carlisle road